Timeliness and effectiveness of progeny testing through artificial insemination.

Progeny-test (PT) programs of US artificial-insemination (AI) organizations were examined to determine timeliness of sampling, PT daughter distribution, rate of return of PT bulls to widespread service, and genetic merit of PT bulls compared with AI-proven and natural-service (NS) bulls. Bull age at semen release and at birth and calving of PT daughters was documented by breed (Ayrshire, Brown Swiss, Guernsey, Holstein, Jersey, and Milking Shorthorn) for bulls that entered AI service since 1960. Mean Holstein bull age at semen release (16 mo) changed little over time, but standard deviations (SD) decreased from 4.0 mo during the 1960s to 2.4 mo during the 1990s. Most Holstein bulls (80%) had semen released by 18 mo. Mean age of Holstein bulls at birth and calving of PT daughters during the 1990s was 29 and 56 mo, respectively (a decline of 4 mo from the 1960s); SD decreased from 6 to 3 mo. Bulls of other breeds usually were older at birth and calving of PT daughters, and SD were larger. Mean Holstein bull age when 80% of PT daughters had been born declined from 36 mo during the 1960s to 31 mo during the early 1990s; for other breeds, bulls showed the same trend but at older ages. Mean Holstein bull age when 80% of PT daughters had calved declined from 65 mo during the 1960s to 59 mo during the 1990s; for other breeds, bulls were older. Percentage of herds with PT daughters has increased over time. For Holsteins, herds with five or more usable first-parity records that had PT daughters with usable records increased from 15% during 1965 to 61% during 1998; percentage of herds with from 1 to 19% PT records increased from 11 to 38%, and percentage of herds with >50% PT daughters increased from 1 to 5%. Percentage of Holstein PT bulls returned to AI service declined to about 12% for bulls with PT entry around 1990; for other breeds, 12 to 23% of most recent PT bulls were returned to service. Percentage of milking daughters that had records usable for genetic evaluation that were sired by PT bulls increased steadily from 10 to 18%, whereas percentage of daughters with usable records that were sired by NS bulls declined from 14 to 7%. Milk yield of daughters of AI-proven bulls was 107 to 200 kg greater than for daughters of PT bulls and 366 to 444 kg greater than for daughters of NS bulls for all years. More extensive and rapid sampling and increased selection intensity of PT programs have led to more rapid genetic progress. More extensive use of AI could increase US producer income by millions of dollars annually.